Book Review: barebones. A Surgeons’s Tale. by Augusto Sarmiento, MD

 by James D. Hundley, MD

barebones is the inspirational story of a bright, ambitious young man imbued with an iron will and an unwavering inspiration to benefit society through Medicine in general and Orthopaedic Surgery in specific.  This review is not intended to be comprehensive nor do I expect book reports to become a routine of the OrthopaedicLIST.com blog.  It’s simply that Dr. Sarmiento’s life history and his views are so interesting and compelling that I wish every orthopaedic surgeon and resident in training, indeed every physician in the United States, would read it.  As for immigrant physicians, Dr. Sarmiento’s story could well become their Bibles.

The story is well written and describes Dr. Sarmiento’s life and his family struggles when he was a young man through his medical training in Colombia to his orthopaedic residency in the U.S. as an immigrant who could barely speak English to his rise to prominence as an innovator, researcher, academician, and chair of three departments of orthopaedic surgery (two in the U.S. and one in Scotland).  Being elected President of the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons, the largest and among the most prestigious of orthopaedic surgeon associations is evidence of the esteem by which he was held by his fellow surgeons.

As a resident in orthopaedic surgery in the late 60’s and early 70’s I well remember his innovative, dynamic treatment of long bone fractures as it rose to prominence.  I was fortunate to have received my training in a conservative program where the closed treatment of fractures was the first consideration and ORIF was simply one of the choices.  Moving from a long-leg cast to a PTB one for tibia fractures was a huge advance for our patients.

Dr. Sarmiento’s interest and expertise in the treatment of adult hip problems was not as well known, but he contributed significantly to that field as well.

The most compelling message from the book relates to Dr. Sarmiento’s observations of the changes in focus by some orthopaedic surgeons during his career.  Dr. Sarmiento was steadfast in putting the interests of his patients first and foremost while having to fight bureaucrats in hospitals and academic centers as well as politicians and observing and feeling the effects of powerful, fellow orthopaedic surgeons who put self interest before that of their patients and medical centers.

He also documents the efforts and effects of the powerful orthopaedic companies whose “good business” practices were not necessarily “good for patient” practices and believes that these companies have almost taken over the postgraduate education of orthopaedic surgeons.  He believes that the spiraling cost of medical care is one of the unfortunate side effects of that particular shift in source and surgeons practice “cosmetic bone surgery”, surgery that is not indicated for human function.

My only criticism of the book is that Dr. Sarmiento tends to paint our profession with a broad brush of negativity and, like most of us, is concerned that our medical profession will not continue to attract the best and brightest to become physicians.  Fortunately, the numbers and academic qualifications for those applying to medical schools have never been higher.  Hopefully those people will also make good doctors, a concern also addressed by Dr. Sarmiento.

I wish that I could require every orthopaedic surgeon, resident and practitioner, to read Dr. Sarmiento’s barebones.  As that is not within my power, I can only hope that this brief review will entice more to do so.

barebones.  A Surgeon’s Tale by Augusto Sarmiento, MD, Prometheus Books, 59 John Glenn Drive, Amherst, New York 14228-2197, www.prometheusbooks.com, Published 2003, 379 pages

Dr. Hundley is a retired orthopaedic surgeon living in Wilmington, NC and president of OrthopaedicLIST.com.